What the DOT requires airlines to report
The U.S. Department of Transportation’s animal-incident rule begins with a size test. A carrier comes under it by flying at least one aircraft built for 60 or more passengers, and from that point any animal it loses, injures or kills on a scheduled domestic or international passenger flight has to be reported.
The filing duty is not annual. A report is due for each month in which something went wrong, which is why the counts arrive as monthly filings rather than one yearly total. DOT’s own Air Travel Consumer Report names 14 CFR Part 235 as the authority behind the requirement, though the material reviewed here does not reproduce the full rule text or point to a more specific subsection.
Two boundaries follow, and both shape what the data can show. The threshold is set by fleet rather than by animals carried, and the scope covers scheduled passenger flights, not cargo-only moves or charters.
Why there is no airline pet-safety ranking
A rate needs two things: a count of incidents and a count of animals flown. DOT supplies the first consistently for its reporting carriers and publishes carrier-level animal totals in some monthly reports, but those totals cover only a slice of the industry.
The gaps are widest outside the United States. Reporting windows shift from year to year, carriers outside the DOT system leave no trace, and no comparable counts of animals carried exist for every route an animal might take. No public series that lines carriers up on deaths, injuries, losses and animals carried could be verified for ANA, Japan Airlines, Cathay Pacific, Singapore Airlines, Qantas or Air New Zealand in the sources reviewed here.
A blank cell in that comparison is not a clean record, and it is not proof of a problem either. It means only that no comparable figure was published, which is a different claim from a carrier having no incidents at all.
Singapore’s import rules do impose one duty in this area. An airline must alert authorities if an animal being brought into the country gets loose, but that is a notification requirement rather than a published comparison, and it produces no carrier-by-carrier numbers.
One figure still gets cited long after it stopped describing current performance. American Airlines recorded 0.71 incidents per 10,000 animals transported during its PetEmbark period from 2015 to 2020, and that six-year average belongs in the historical column. DOT has kept publishing since — American material for 2025, plus Air Travel Consumer Reports dated 2026 — but no newer multi-year average for the carrier surfaced in this research.
Superdeals cover departures from North America, Europe and Australia.
Flight deals most people never see
Air Traveler Club monitors thousands of routes for pricing anomalies that traditional search engines miss. With ATC Superdeals members save up to 80% on each flight vs. regular fares.
Too good to be true? Check it out yourself. It's free.
Delivered weekly. Unsubscribe anytime.
Flight 60: one incident, fully documented
Alaska Airlines Flight 60 was a transfer at Seattle on December 17, 2010. A pin missing from a kennel door let an eight-month-old mixed-breed dog escape its crate. An airport search began once the loss was noticed, and a private tracking effort later joined it.
Neither effort found the dog. It was found dead on January 6, 2011 near a highway, apparently struck by a car, and the DOT file records the escape mechanism and the search response along with that outcome.
What the incident table cannot capture
Two risks sit outside any carrier ranking. Snub-nosed breeds carry a documented respiratory vulnerability, and sedating an animal before a flight can compound it. Both shape how an owner picks a route, and neither changes an airline’s place in a table built from incident counts.
Temperature is the other routine constraint: carriers commonly stop accepting animals once conditions reach 85°F at the hot end or 20°F at the cold end. Those embargoes are carrier policy rather than a DOT metric, so a trip moved or cancelled on temperature grounds never appears in the data.
Key terms
- Air Travel Consumer Report
- The Air Travel Consumer Report is the Department of Transportation’s publication for airline consumer metrics, and it is where the department’s animal-incident material appears. It carries incident filings from covered U.S. carriers and, in some editions, carrier-level totals for animals transported — the closest thing to a public denominator this research located. Because its scope is U.S. carriers, it cannot settle a question about a foreign airline’s record, even when both names sit in the same comparison.
- 14 CFR Part 235
- 14 CFR Part 235 is the rule that current DOT consumer-report material identifies as the authority behind the animal-incident reporting requirement. It applies to a U.S. carrier that flies at least one aircraft designed to seat 60 or more passengers, and it requires a filing for any month in which an animal was lost, injured or killed on a scheduled passenger flight. What circulates here is the citation rather than the text, so anyone weighing an enforcement argument should read the section itself before relying on it.
- Reporting carrier
- A reporting carrier is a U.S. airline that meets the DOT size threshold and therefore files animal-incident reports with the department. The label follows the fleet rather than the traffic: an operator qualifies by flying aircraft built for 60 or more passengers, not by the number of animals it moves. Because the test is an aircraft, a regional operator whose planes fall below it sends nothing to DOT at all, however many animals it carries.
- Snub-nosed breed
- A snub-nosed breed is a dog or cat with a flattened muzzle and a shortened airway, the shape that gives these animals their characteristic profile. The research reviewed here notes a documented respiratory vulnerability in these breeds, which makes breathing a fragile thing under the stress of transport. Sedation is the compounding factor: an animal already working harder to breathe can be pushed further by a pre-flight sedative, so the breathing profile of the individual matters more than the airline’s published rate.
Frequently asked questions
Was Alaska Airlines penalized after the Flight 60 escape?
No. The DOT report records the escape mechanism, the search response and the fatal outcome, but it documents no fine or enforcement action against the carrier.
What happens to an animal that survives an injury in transit?
The public record stops at the incident. No authoritative airline-wide dataset on long-term health outcomes for animals that survive an in-transit injury was identified in this research, so the DOT filings count losses, injuries and deaths without following what happens next.